Juvenile justice system should focus on punishment

The main reason behind this finding is the fact that the causes of the juvenile offences are never addressed while they are in custody.

When an individual commits a crime at such a young age, the most likely scenario is that the crime was produced by a lack of resources and sufficient education, rather than pure malice.

How juvenile courts operate may vary from county to county and municipality to municipality within a state. Observations were based on spatial and temporal sampling, with shifts representing all times of the day and all days of the week.

Additionally, punishment on its own does not result to minimization of juvenile delinquency.

Should the juvenile criminal justice system focus on rehabilitation, punishment, or both?

A population such as this will be much better served by community-based mental health treatment, rather than detainment behind bars. Florida prohibits life imprisonment for juveniles convicted for non-homicide offenses. It will be defined as programs and therapies that will allow any Juvenile delinquent to reenter the society as a contributing member to their community.

The answer is relatively easy, when a criminal is faced with punishment or rehabilitation they will almost universally choose rehabilitation. Amendments to the act in weakened the deinstitutionalization mandate somewhat by allowing detention and incarceration of noncriminal juveniles for violating a valid court order.

Gault was detained by the police and held overnight without his parents being notified; he was required to appear at a juvenile court hearing the following day; a probation officer filed a pro forma petition alleging Gault was a delinquent minor in need of care and custody of the court; no witnesses were called; there was no sworn testimony or written record of the court proceedings; and Gault was not advised of his right to remain silent or to have an attorney.

They succeeded in diverting most children and adolescents from the criminal system, but they may Page Share Cite Suggested Citation: In fact, because of their criminal record and deficit in education, juvenile delinquents, even those who have been reformed, will find extreme difficulty becoming productive members of society.

Looking for other ways to read this?

Report this Argument Pro Hello, I would like to begin by thanking you for bringing up some things that I failed to explain better, as well as saying your welcome for bringing up this topic to debate. Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsIssue 2.

The Saint Anselm Crier

In addition to the belief that at least some juvenile offenders are amenable to treatment and rehabilitation, other factors limit overreliance on get-tough measures: I would submit that the reason that youth feel much more "brave" today is actually due to their knowledge of what punishment entails.

A demographic breakdown of youth in the United States. For example, a study by Greenwood et al. Law enforcement agencies account for the vast majority—86 percent in —of delinquency referrals Stahl et al.

Should the Juvenile Justice System Should Focus

Status offenders who did not comply with treatment ordered by the court could become criminal delinquents by virtue of being charged with criminal contempt of court. The nature of the juvenile justice system was paternalistic and non-adversarial. Most of these contacts are undocumented and of low visibility Goldstein, ; only a fraction reach the attention of juvenile court judges or youth detention authorities.

Practice may also move in ways not envisioned when laws are passed. Often there is a belief that the harsher the punishment the less likely Juveniles will re-offend. When this report refers to the juvenile justice system, it is referring to a generic framework that is more or less representative of what happens in any given state.

Department of Justice, has collected and analyzed juvenile court statistics since Each state and the District of Columbia has its own laws that govern its juvenile justice system. Therefore there is no need to give juvenile offenders that chance so that they can change for the betterment of the society The League of Young Voters, During the last decade, the number of juveniles committing murder, rape, robbery and assault has increased by a whopping 93 percent.

The process of permitting juvenile court judges to make waiver determinations based upon a case-specific evaluation is consistent with case law, which since has sought to balance the need to afford juveniles the added protection of the juvenile courts while ensuring that their constitutional rights, the same as those granted to adult offenders were not abridged.

The aim of each of the mentioned therapies and programs is to modify an area that requires an improvement or correction. The primary purpose and necessity for transferring juvenile offenders to criminal court is in those instances when the maximum punishment in juvenile court is clearly inadequate for a particular offender, not a class of offenders.

Finley argues for early intervention in juvenile delinquency, and advocates for the development of programs that are more centered on rehabilitation rather than punishment. These changes are described following a description of the current juvenile justice system processes.

Maintaining an atmosphere of fear is necessary to deter criminals, especially youth, and so it is necessary to avoid promoting rehabilitation. This same philosophy should remain applicable and binding where legislative or prosecutorial waiver is employed.

This system was to differ from adult or criminal court in a number of ways. Alabama held that mandatory life sentences without the possibility of parole are unconstitutional for juveniles. Community-based treatment of juvenile offenders not only would fail to provide enough punishment for offenders, but also would fail to prevent juvenile crime from occurring in the first place.

Punishment In The Juvenile Justice System

In court, children as young as seven were treated as adults and could receive the death penalty. Contrary to judicial waiver, legislative waiver is automatic. The discretion exercised by the juvenile court judge is neither arbitrary nor capricious.

Judges may have preconceptions of the credibility of police and probation officers and of the juvenile in question. A national debate has arisen over the types of changes that states have made, which include transferring jurisdiction over juveniles from juvenile court to adult court, imposing stronger sentences on juvenile delinquents, and lessening the confidential nature of juvenile proceedings.

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A new report says the current juvenile probation system just doesn't work - and should be revamped to focus on helping kids rather than punishing them and making them comply.

When you say “Why should juvenile justice focus on rehabilitation,” it’s actually a very simple answer — because they will one day walk through the front door and become part of our society again. Ironically, the United States was the first country in the world to create a separate justice system for juveniles.

Inthe country’s first juvenile court was established in Cook County, Illinois. Should the Juvenile Justice system should focus on rehabilitation CSS/ January 17, University Of Phoenix There has been much of a debate over whether or not punishment or rehabilitation should be the prime focus of the Juvenile Justice system.

b Toshiba Justice System Position Kimberly Gaudiosi Emmalee The topic of juvenile justice is a broad one but one that should concern everyone. My standpoint on this debatable topic is that the juvenile justice system should focus on the rehabilitation of the teens rather than making them pay for their crimes with an extensive jail sentence as a punishment.

The question continually raised is whether the juvenile justice system should be abandoned in favor of transferring juvenile offenders to adult courts and prisons and, perhaps, even death row.

is consistent with much of society's desire to focus solely on punishment as opposed to to criminal court is in those instances when the maximum.

Juvenile justice system should focus on punishment
Rated 3/5 based on 49 review
Juvenile Justice at the Crossroads